Recent social media posts
11/03/2025
Hello & goodbye,
As many of you know , I had the store property up for sale. It sold- very quickly- was a surprise to me.
The new owner “Goodies Unlimited “ has bought me out and will running the store. I wish them the best!!
Thank you for 20+ years of friendship and business.. I am looking forward to slowing down and seeing what life brings now.
Thank- you ,
Kim & Parker
10/16/2025
It’s not too late to decorate … and we have kids costumes!! $7
10/01/2025
Halloween is here - come check out our decorations n costumes ( $7 each) and Christmas is around the corner… putting new things out each week!
08/28/2025
The weather can’t decide if summer or fall.. so we have alittle of everything out!! Come and check out our grills for your Labor Day parties. And then pick up a Halloween costume for spooky day.
07/17/2025
New patio furniture n summer items! Come check us out- we are restocking daily!
06/20/2025
Summer is here… come check out fans, pool toys n summer fun items. Also full line of small kitchen appliances. All shirts are $1 and shorts , capris $3. Men’s women’s n kids!!
05/02/2025
Summer is finally here! We have chairs , umbrella n tables!! Also full line of new furniture- new things are coming out every day.
And be sure and stop and say hello to our reader, Parker 
03/28/2025
Spring is here!! We have umbrellas n new things to make your summer better 🌻🌞. Come in and visit- open Wednesday to Saturdays
Address
1554 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA
17015
To reach Holly Pike in Carlisle using public transport, you can take the bus to the nearest stop and then walk to your destination. If you prefer to drive, you can take the highway and exit at the designated exit for Holly Pike. Parking options are available along the street or in nearby parking lots.
Opening Hours
| Wednesday |
10:01am - 5pm |
| Thursday |
10:01am - 5pm |
| Friday |
10am - 5pm |
| Saturday |
10am - 3pm |
Alerts
Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Potteiger's Curiosity Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
What people say
Potteiger's Curiosity Shop on Holly Pike is a hidden gem that offers a delightful mix of new and used furniture, pet supplies, and various household essentials. This charming local business has been making waves in the community with its unique offerings and friendly service.
One of the standout features of Potteiger's Curiosity Shop is their ever-changing inventory that keeps customers coming back for more. Whether you're looking for a quirky piece of furniture to add character to your home or stocking up on pet supplies, this shop has it all. The eclectic mix of items, from paper goods to electronics, ensures that there is something for everyone.
The team at Potteiger's Curiosity Shop clearly takes pride in curating a diverse selection of products for their customers. Their social media updates showcase their enthusiasm for each season, whether it's decking the halls with Christmas trees and decorations or gearing up for summer picnics with tents and coolers.
What sets Potteiger's Curiosity Shop apart is their commitment to offering affordable options without compromising on quality. From $1 summer clothes to discounted dog costumes, they make sure that everyone can find something special without breaking the bank.
If you're in the Carlisle area, be sure to stop by Potteiger's Curiosity Shop on Holly Pike. You never know what treasures you might uncover or what new arrivals will catch your eye. It's a place where curiosity meets convenience, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.
